Module A: Textual Conversations is all about analysing how texts interact- examining how they influence, mirror, or challenge one another.
For Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes, this means unpacking a deeply personal and literary dialogue filled with love, loss, betrayal, and healing.
Understanding Module A means understanding how texts are shaped by their contexts and how these conversations reveal deeper insights. To ace your Module A essay, you need to unpack these connections and explore how their works respond to each other within their historical and personal contexts.
Think of a comparative essay as a conversation between two texts. For Plath and Hughes, this conversation is as raw and personal as it gets. Your job? To analyse their similarities, differences, and how context shapes their works.
Imagine you’re hosting a dinner party with Plath and Hughes at the table. What topics would they discuss? Mental health? Identity? Betrayal? How do their perspectives clash or align? That’s your comparative analysis.
Key questions to ask:
The textual conversation between Plath and Hughes stems from their tumultuous personal and literary relationship. Sylvia Plath, an American confessional poet, explores themes of mental illness, gender roles, and personal trauma. Ted Hughes, an English poet, was known for his powerful and often dark explorations of nature, mythology, and masculinity. Their romantic relationship, filled with love and turmoil, is reflected in their work. Plath wrote about personal trauma and oppression, often depicting herself as the victim of patriarchal forces. Hughes, responding posthumously in Birthday Letters, sought to reframe Plath’s narrative, challenging the feminist critique of him as her oppressor.
Their poetry, particularly Plath’s Daddy and Hughes’ The Shot, provides a textual conversation about power, agency, and psychological turmoil. Plath’s work explores oppression and a desperate need for liberation, while Hughes’ poem shifts the blame from himself to Plath’s unresolved attachment to her father. Understanding these perspectives allows students to engage deeply with the resonances (similarities) and dissonances (contrasts) between the texts.
Plath’s Daddy is an intense, emotionally charged poem that explores themes of oppression, loss, and psychological struggle. She likens her father to authoritarian figures such as Hitler, illustrating her deep resentment and unresolved trauma. Plath's use of violent imagery, confessional tone, and allusions to history and myth create a harrowing portrait of her struggles with identity and male dominance.
Hughes' The Shot serves as a direct response to Plath's suffering, framing her as a bullet propelled by fate, unstoppable in her trajectory towards self-destruction. The poem reflects on her relentless pursuit of an idealised father figure and the emotional toll it took on those around her.
Plath’s Daddy is a powerful expression of patriarchal oppression, reflecting the psychological trauma and loss of agency experienced by women in a male-dominated society. The poem is deeply personal, yet also universal in its critique of the structures that disempower women.
Metaphor & Symbolism: Plath compares herself to a Jewish victim of the Holocaust, comparing her father to a Nazi oppressor—"Chuffing me off like a Jew… to Dachau, to Auschwitz, Belsen." This visceral imagery equates her suffering to one of history’s greatest atrocities, exaggerating the scale of her oppression.
Violent Imagery: The culmination of the poem, “Daddy, daddy, you bastard, I’m through,” marks Plath’s rejection of her father’s control and, metaphorically, male oppression. The expletive, coupled with the abrupt finality, signifies her attempt to reclaim power.
Plath’s Daddy is thus not just a personal outpouring but a broader commentary on the victimisation of women. The poem explores how patriarchal structures infiltrate personal relationships, leaving women psychologically enslaved.
Hughes’ “The Shot” serves as a dissonant response to “Daddy”, presenting an alternative perspective on Plath’s struggles. Instead of patriarchal oppression, Hughes attributes her suffering to an internal psychological battle, portraying her as trapped in a cycle of self-destruction caused by her unresolved fixation on her father.
Extended Metaphor: The opening lines, “Your daddy had been aiming you at God, when his death touched the trigger” establish the poem’s controlling metaphor. Hughes likens Plath to a bullet, suggesting she was set on a predetermined, destructive path from childhood. This dismisses external oppression and instead shifts blame to her internal psyche.
Anaphora & Distance: In “A wisp of your hair, your ring, your watch, your nightgown”, Hughes lists impersonal material objects left behind after her death. The use of anaphora reinforces his sense of helplessness and emotional detachment, framing him as a powerless bystander rather than an agent in her suffering.
In The Shot, Hughes seeks to redefine Plath’s victimhood. While she viewed herself as oppressed by male figures, he frames her as psychologically entrapped by her obsession with Otto. This drastically alters the conversation, shifting the focus from external oppression to internal turmoil.
Now that we’ve explored key themes and techniques, here’s how you can structure your essay effectively. Notice how each paragraph follows a thematic structure, integrating both texts for a strong comparative analysis.
Plath utilises ‘Daddy’ to portray women’s desire for liberty in a contextual society of oppressive males as she attempts to emancipate herself as a disempowered victim from a degraded mental state. Plath’s inability to form meaningful relationships with men arose following the death of her father, Otto, which scarred her with emotional trauma and depression.
Hence, Plath emphasises the oppression from masculine figures as the catalyst for her psychological trauma and degraded autonomy, highlighting that only the liberation of these issues can help her achieve self-empowerment.
Contrastingly in ‘The Shot’, Hughes’ dissonant perspective asserts his innocence by claiming that Plath’s lack of autonomy arises not from patriarchal oppression, but her fixation and morbid obsession to reunite with Otto. Following the immense criticism and scrutiny from the burgeoning feminist movement in 1963, Hughes wrote “Birthday Letters” to absolve himself from contributions to Plath’s suicide.
Thus, Hughes effectively disputes Plath’s portrayal of patriarchal oppression by reframing her desire for paternal reconnection as the impetus that led to her internal conflict and eventual demise.
Mastering Module A requires more than just understanding individual texts—it’s about developing strong comparative skills that allow you to analyse how texts resonate and dissonate with one another. By focusing on key themes, literary techniques, and contextual influences, you can craft sophisticated responses that showcase a deep engagement with textual conversations.
If you’re looking for expert guidance to refine your essay writing, strengthen your analysis, and boost your HSC English results, Gold Standard Academy (GSA) is here to help. Our experienced tutors offer personalised coaching on Module A, as well as other HSC English modules and subjects. Whether you need targeted feedback, structured lessons, or exam preparation, sign up today and take your English skills to the next level!
We provide specialised English tutoring for students in Years 7 to 12, ensuring they build strong foundational skills and excel in their senior studies.
Yes, all our lessons are carefully aligned with the NSW syllabus to ensure students are prepared for school assessments, exams, and their HSC requirements.
We start by assessing each student’s strengths, weaknesses, and learning style. Our tutors then tailor lesson plans to address specific goals and areas of improvement, ensuring targeted and effective learning.
All our classes are one-on-one. This allows us to accommodate different learning preferences, ensuring each student receives the attention and support they need.
Absolutely. Our tutors are experienced in guiding students through preparing for specific assessments, exams, and assignments, providing targeted feedback and strategies to help them succeed.
Yes, we provide weekly content, comprehensive resources, including practice materials, worksheets, and model responses, to help students consolidate their learning and practice independently.
Typically, each session is 60 minutes. Our termly courses are at least once a week, but the frequency can be tailored based on their needs and academic goals.
Yes, we offer both in-person and online tutoring to accommodate different preferences and ensure flexibility in learning.
Yes, we offer new students trial lessons with no obligation to continue for the entire term to help them experience our teaching approach and determine if it’s the right fit for their learning needs.
You can contact us either through our email at tutor@goldstandardacademy.com or call us at 0481 336 988
